What to sing, what to sing?
When you have the opportunity to sit in at someone else’s gig and sing a tune, or if you're at an open mic where there’s a jazz trio or a pianist, what criteria do you use to choose which song you will sing?
Last night, I was at Wanda Stafford’s gig at the Panama Hotel in San Rafael. It was a special night because Wanda was celebrating her birthday (I'm not sure which one and I wasn't going to ask her) so there was a slew of singers there, singers who knew and loved Wanda and wanted to join the celebration. Almost every single one of them got up to sing a song that night.
Everyone except me.
Why? Well, this is what I realized. I didn't really have a song that fit the spirit of the evening AND was charted well enough for the band to play easily. I didn't have a song I was really dying to sing. I didn't have a song that would allow me to contribute positively to what was being created by these other singers or allow me to represent what I do well. So, I took photos instead.
But it made me realize, I want to be better prepared for such occasions. I need to have 2-3 songs, each one representing a different mood, tempo and energy, that are well charted and ready to go any time I want to sit in.
When I go to open mics, I usually just sing whatever I am working on at the time. Open mics, for me, are a chance to work on new material, a chance to perform songs I've never performed before or songs I'm still needing to work through in some way.
But last night was a different deal. It was Wanda’s gig, Wanda’s show, and what I noticed was that as different singers sat in, there was a party energy and up-beat mood of aliveness that was being created, a jazzy high of up-tempo music. I wasn't going to get up there and kill the buzz by singing “The Nearness of You.” I mean, it would have been fine, but it wouldn't have added to what was being created.
My friend Terese Genecco was there with me. She, too, was trying to decide what to sing. Luckily, she has charts that are very well written, charts from her great show, “Drunk With Love — a Tribute to Francis Faye.” As we were discussing which song she should sing, there was one song we decided she shouldn't do because it felt too big for the room and the refined, sassy style of Wanda’s singing.
But after several different singers got up to sing, that all changed. I could feel the energy build in the room as singer after singer got up to sing songs of different genres and styles. The singer before Terese sang “Won’t You Come Home, Bill Baily,” with this full-out, fun, wise-woman gusto. She set a mood that was perfect for that song of Terese’s we had previously nixed.
So, we changed our minds, again. I told Terese to go for it, sing “Unchain My Heart” and she blew the audience away with her huge, full-out vocal power and charisma. It was the perfect choice.
The way I see it, the trick is to have 2-3 songs, at least, that you can throw in front of a band or pianist and sing really well. Each song should fit a certain mood or genre. If I'm in a jazz club, I'm not going to sing some power ballad from “Dream Girls” (not that I'd ever sing a song from “Dream Girls”, but you get what I mean).
If you only get to sing one song all evening, pick one that:
-
Fits or complements the mood, energy and atmosphere that has been created by the singer or musician whose gig it is.
-
Can be easily read and played by the band or pianist (don't show up with some Sondheim 25-page long mini-aria and throw that in front of a pianist and expect him or her to play well. Or at all.)
-
Allows you to shine and show off the best of what you can do.
Now, sometimes, you just want to sing a song because you want to sing it and you don't care if it fits the mood or energy of what’s happening. You just want to perform it because you do. And that’s okay, too. I'm just saying that, for myself, I'm going to clean up a few charts so that in the future I have 2-3 songs that can kick ass next time I'm asking to sit in.
Tags: singer, music, performance, song